Welcome



 

Karlsbad 1907

Product Code: B0011CA

Description


Publisher: Caissa Editions
Author: George Marco & Carl Schlechter
Year of Publication: 2007

Pages: 448
Notation Type: Algebraic (AN)


Book DescriptionAn English translation of this original famous tournament book in German by George Marco and Carl Schlechter. This edition has the advantage of enhancements such as the addition of 15 photos of many of the players along with corrections and additional analysis using the new, very strong program, Rybka. The tournament was one of the strongest of the last century with only Lasker, Tarrasch and Burn, missing from the roster of the world's best players of that day. The young player Rubinstein won in fine style followed by Maroczy just one-half point behind and by Leonhardt, Nimzovich/Schlechter, Vidmar, Duras/Teichmann, Salwe, Wolf, Dus-Chotimirski/Marshall, Spielmann, Tartakower, Berger/Mieses/Chigorin, Olland, E. Cohn, and Johner in that order. This was to be the Chigorin's last tournament, though he still showed flashes of his brilliance in individual games. Marco and Schlechter contributed superb notes in a style combining wit, depth, and accuracy. 448 pages, hardback, on acid-free paper. This is the gem of all tournament books.

Media Mail Eligible

Media Mail® shipping from the US Postal Service is the cost-effective way to ship Books, Software and DVDs. With shipping rates starting at only $5.00, it's the most affordable shipping method available.

Reviews

Customer Reviews

by jerry silman Review by leo3780
Rating
This legendary tournament book has long been available in German, but English-speaking fans were left out in the cold. Now, thanks to Caissa Editions, an English translation is finally available. Fortunately the editor, Mr. Dale Brandreth, didn’t stop there. He tossed in 15 wonderful photos and had Robert Sherwood (using Rybka) check for analytical errors.

This event featured a veritable parade of famous players. The twenty-one competitors were (in order of final placing): Rubinstein (with an amazing 15-5 total), Maroczy, Leonhardt, Nimzovich, Schlechter, Vidmar, Duras, Teichmann, Salwe, Wolf, Dus-Chotimirsky, Marshall, Spielmann, Tartakover, Janowsky, Berger, Mieses, Chigorin (his final tournament), Dr. Olland, E.Cohn, and Johner. The only chess giants missing from this lineup were Lasker, Tarrasch, and Amos Burn.

Karlsbad 1907 begins with a fascinating Introduction that not only gives us a history of Karlsbad’s ties with chess (it hosted a match between Albin and Marco in 1901 and another match between Janowsky and Schlechter in 1902) and how this event came to be, but also discusses the prize fund, the dates and times of the games, rules relating to adjournments and ties, some really fascinating newspaper accounts of the event, and quite a bit more.

After the Introduction we get a very nice full page crosstable of the tournament that highlights individual scores and final places, followed by another full page crosstable showing us round by round scores. Then we come to the real meat of the book: Every round gets a nice discussion followed by the pairings, results, and openings for each game. And this leads us into the games themselves, every one (210 in all!) deeply annotated by Marco and Schlechter (Marco annotated games 1 though 151 and also game 206, while Schlecter did the analysis for games 152-205 and games 207 to 210).

Keep in mind that Georg Marco was both an excellent player and a very fine annotator, while Schlecter almost beat Lasker in a World Championship match (Lasker tied the match by winning the final game in dramatic fashion). I personally found Marco’s notes to be colorful and instructive. I also loved the fact that he didn’t pull any punches. For example, in his notes to game 120 (Tartakover-Duras) he said, "Tartakover’s individual moves, considered in and of themselves, are not bad, but taken together they show us that his conduct of the game is entirely misguided. White’s pawn storm has arrived at a pitiful standstill, while Black’s pawns roll toward the white King like an avalanche.”

Marco makes his views known in every game, tossing in a cascade of analysis at one moment, deep instruction the next, and attacks against the ignorant if he felt it was warranted. Here’s another note (to game 126) that gives you a taste of the fire in his pen: "A well-known critic says, ‘14...Nd7 15.Nf5 Nf8, followed by ...Ng6, came into consideration.’ He is completely correct, for in a tournament game one should ‘consider’ everything. But such an enjoinder by itself is of no help – one must be able to decide whether the maneuver is as good or better than others. But it is concerning just this that the critic gives no further information.”

His note to move 6 (after 1.d4 Nf6 2.Nf3 d6 3.Nc3 g6 4.e4 Bg7 5.h3 Nc6 6.Bf4) of game 129 (Schlechter-Chigorin) shows his dedication to discussing ideas and not just moves to the chess student: "Beginners and experienced players alike have struggled in such situations with the question whether e4-e5 will prove to be unpleasant for White or for Black. For the student, such considerations, repeated a hundred-fold, are certainly beneficial; for the tournament player, they are not only superfluous but are even harmful, as they simply waste time. As Polaris does for the sailor, Philidor’s rule must serve as a lodestar. This rule says that the advance of a pawn to the fifth rank (especially in the opening) offers the opponent an object of attack, whose defense leads either to the opening of the position or to the freeing of the enemy forces. Hence Chigorin seeks (as in game 108) to provoke e4-e5 or d4-d5.”
 (Posted on 11/25/2017)

Write Your Own Review

You're reviewing: Karlsbad 1907

How do you rate this product? *

  1 star 2 stars 3 stars 4 stars 5 stars
Rating
$54.95


Product Details

Additional Information

ISBN 9781162411156
Manufacturer Caissa Editions
Author/s Alexander Ilyin-Genevsky
Pages 448 Pages
Publication Date Jan 1, 2007
Notation Type AN - Algebraic
Book Binding Type Hardcover